September 08, 2025
In today’s rapidly evolving political climate, engaging students in American politics requires a delicate balance. Educators face the challenge of fostering critical thinking without veering into partisan bias or despair.
As many of you may know, my academic journey has been rooted in political science, with a focus on teaching Introduction to American Government. This course has always been a rewarding experience, filled with lively discussions and debates.
However, I find myself questioning the effectiveness of teaching this subject in the current environment.
While certain foundational elements remain intact—such as the existence of the Electoral College and the structure of Congress—many principles we once considered stable have become increasingly contentious.
Take the concept of checks and balances, for instance. There was a time when we believed that no single branch of government could overpower the others to the point of undermining established norms. Yet, the current political landscape challenges that assumption. Teaching checks and balances now feels disingenuous, as does discussing judicial review, the importance of precedent, and the independence of the judiciary. These concepts have shifted from being accepted truths to subjects of intense debate.
In the past, the primary hurdle in my classes was often correcting misconceptions that students brought with them from their families, workplaces, and societal narratives. Many of these ideas were either inaccurate or overly simplistic. For example, I frequently encountered students who, upon learning that each state has two senators, would ask, “One from each party, right?” This kind of misunderstanding was common but manageable.
Today, however, the landscape has changed dramatically. The challenge now lies in combating a pervasive culture of misinformation. An entire industry has emerged that thrives on fabricating narratives, making it difficult to discern fact from fiction. In this new political reality, even basic fact-checking is often dismissed as partisan bias. Why bother with the truth when one can simply create their own version of reality?
Moreover, the rise of artificial intelligence has introduced another layer of complexity, as it can generate subpar academic work with alarming ease.
In light of these challenges, it may be tempting to abandon the effort altogether. Indeed, enrollment numbers in political science courses are declining, and I understand why. Yet, there is a compelling case to be made for the importance of political literacy now more than ever. We are witnessing unprecedented actions, such as the current president using military force to intimidate cities that opposed him. This situation represents a significant departure from traditional checks and balances, and young people will bear the consequences of these actions for years to come. The argument for ignoring these issues has never been weaker.
Thus, I pose a question to my insightful readers: Have you or anyone you know discovered effective methods to engage students in American politics thoughtfully, avoiding the pitfalls of partisanship and cynicism? I would love to hear your thoughts and experiences.
4/5 Articles remaining this month.
Sign up for a free account or log in.